Saturday, May 7, 2016

Comments from the De Soto Book Discussion Group regarding our May 2016 selection:

Before I Go 

by Colleen Oakley 

Our group discussion shows a mix of reactions to Before I Go.  

As Daisy gets ready to celebrate her four year cancerversary, or life without cancer, she discovers there is now Lots of Cancer throughout her whole body including a tumor the size of an orange in her brain. Daisy is given 6 months to a year to live. During that time Daisy plans to fix up her house and see her husband, Jack, complete the dual PhD and DVM in veterinary medicine. Another item on Daisy’s to-do list is finding Jack a new wife because he will need someone to take care of him. Daisy begins trying to meet women in coffee shops and starts internet dating for Jack. This turns out to be harder than she imagines.

Most members enjoy the touching story and conversational language of the novel. Cancer is a difficult topic to deal with and it is hard to know Daisy is dying. But the novel is heartfelt and moving. We all appreciate the way Oakley handles the end of this novel and are glad we do not see Daisy severely decline in health.

Others do not like Daisy or the voice of the novel. Admittedly, Daisy does get rather hard to like when she adamantly thinks Jack is cheating on her, but she is going through a hard time. Another drawback of the novel is too many adjectives making one member feel the writing is lacking.  The present tense of the novel is distracting for another member.

One thing our members can agree on, Jack is great. His absentminded nature and sweet temperament towards Daisy made him loveable to the group. Everything revolves around Jack’s school. They miss out on spending time together because school comes first. Everything is put off to the future when Jack graduates. Jack needs to finish school for them both. This is a huge goal for them and something to work towards and keeps their minds off the cancer.

Kayleigh is one of the group’s favorite characters because she was the most real. There were many comedic moments from Kayleigh’s misadventures in love and her cursing. We were all sad Daisy pushes Kayleigh away and yells at her about wasting her life with a job she hates. However, it is surprising much time Daisy wastes in pushing Jack away when they should be spending more time together.


Reading books dealing with cancer is tough for our group as the majority of the members had cancer at one point. Congratulations to one special member who is now cancer free!